
Dear Whit,
I have to say I’m kinda impressed. You actually convinced a major Hollywood studio that you could re-imagine a character and world that was created by a respected and admired writer, and no one even knows who you are! That takes nerve, guts, balls, cajones! A little bit of research, and I find that you’re a 29-year old actress with 3 credits on her
IMDB page and no apparent writing experience.
Well, that’s about to change, isn’t it? Thanks to Warner Brothers and Atlas Entertainment, you are now attached to the new
Buffy the Vampire Slayer film. The script isn’t done yet, but apparently the “fresh take” you had on the story in your treatment was enough to sell them.
In
several articles (that seem to be quoting the same interview or press release), you said that you identified with Buffy because you were the same age as the character. I get that. I felt the same way. We went to prom at the same time, graduated the same year, started college together, struggled through first jobs, loves, heartbreaks . But who made Buffy, well, Buffy? Like any character, she was a combination of the talented actor who played her and the person who created her. Without Sarah Michelle Gellar and Joss Whedon, Buffy doesn’t exist.
“…I just loved this character… it was so rare to have a female lead character on TV… who was strong and capable and smart but also allowed to be feminine.” That character you love, Whit? You can’t create her, because someone else already did. She doesn’t exist without them.

Alright, here’s where it gets confusing. This “reimagining” isn’t even technically of the show. Warner Brothers optioned the rights to the film from the company that produced the 1992 movie (you know the one with Kristy Swanson, Luke Perry and Pee-Wee Herman?). Joss Whedon wrote the film, but had little to nothing to do with the finished product. This movie bombed. At best, it’s a campy “cult classic.” It lacked the warmth, intelligence and relevance of the series.
Why would anyone remake, reboot or reimagine a movie that bombed the first time around? For a reboot to be successful, it would have to use elements from the TV series, something that’s impossible because Warner Brothers only owns rights to Buffy (the character) and the general storyline. Everything else we love about the TV series (the Scooby Gang, Angel, Spike, Giles, Sunnydale) ceases to exist in the film world.
So, why would you want to write this movie? Why would you want

to write a movie that couldn’t possibly compete with the series? The only answer I can come up with is greed. Obviously the studio is greedy. Vampires are all the rage right now. Why not jump on the “True Blood- Twilight- Vampire Diaries” craze with your very own smash hit, right?
But I think you have a slightly different motivation, Whit. No one knew who you were a week ago. Pretty soon everyone will know who you are. But there’s more, right? Let’s see, you’re an actress, and you’re blonde (just like Kristy and Sarah!). Gee, I wonder who you think should play Buffy in your “reimagining”?
I hate to break it to you, but the word on Twitter is that they’re considering Beyonce for the part.
Love,
Megan
P.S. Back when the Star Trek “reboot” came out, my brother was righteously indignant about what a terrible idea it was and how J.J. Abrams ruined everything that was good in the world. I made fun of him (naturally). But now, I really get it. Of course, I think this is different (
At least Abrams had an actual career, Rodenberry wasn’t alive and fully capable of writing/directing/producing and Shatner wasn’t still young enough to star), but I totally get how bad it sucks. So, Bri? I am boycotting that movie for you. Hey, better late than never, right? :)